Native history shows that the right to vote can actually be a defeat instead of a victory.
This election year is also the centennial of the Indian Citizenship Act, which made #Indigenous people US citizens (sometimes against their wills), with theoretical voting rights.
hcn.org/issues/56-10/the-nativ…
The Native vote dilemma
Every election year, Indigenous people grapple with whether and how to engage in electoral politics.B. ‘Toastie’ Oaster (High Country News)
Toastie
in reply to Toastie • • •The ICA was part of a greater campaign of assimilation that followed America's failed military genocide of the Indigenous peoples of North America.
The Haudenosaunee Confederacy rejected imposed US citizenship as treasonous, and even now considers it a violation of international law.
Toastie
in reply to Toastie • • •It took decades for all 50 states to actually recognize the voting rights that supposedly came with US citizenship, and even now Native communities face rampant voter suppression and obstacles to participation.
azmirror.com/2024/07/31/my-fir…
My firsthand experience with the unique barriers to voting that face Indigenous Arizonans
Shondiin Silversmith (Arizona Mirror)Toastie
in reply to Toastie • • •And not all Natives want to vote. Some argue that the two US parties are virtually indistinguishable on Indigenous issues like resource extraction. Diné anarchist Klee Benally wrote that "no matter who you vote for, settler colonialism wins."
detritusbooks.com/products/no-…
No Spiritual Surrender: Indigenous Anarchy in Defense of the Sacred by
Detritus BooksToastie
in reply to Toastie • • •Benally rejected voting as a form of consent to be governed. Voting, he reasoned, is maintaining our own colonization.
But other Natives in political spaces question the assumption that voting is an expression of consent, viewing it instead as a tactic.
ndncollective.org/voting-like-…
Voting Like a Radical and Honoring the Complexities of Organizing for Justice - NDN COLLECTIVE
Sarah Manning (NDN COLLECTIVE)Toastie
in reply to Toastie • • •Toastie
in reply to Toastie • • •Native voters are one of the least partisan voting blocs. When you think and plan according to a seven generation timeline, white hand wringing over US elections every few years can be amusing. We were here before America, the saying goes, and we'll be here long after.
ictnews.org/politics/a-century…
Toastie
in reply to Toastie • • •Nevertheless, Natives tend to vote Democrat, and the Native vote sometimes gets credit for swinging the 2020 election for Biden. It could swing this election, too, and Democrats know that.
hcn.org/articles/indigenous-af…
How Indigenous voters swung the 2020 election
Anna V. Smith (High Country News)Toastie
in reply to Toastie • • •Republicans, on the other hand, seem to be overlooking Native voters almost entirely. Project 2025 barely mentions tribes, a miscalculation that shows how the right underestimates Indigenous sovereignty, tribes’ legal rights and political power, according to one expert.
hcn.org/articles/what-project-…
What Project 2025 has to say about Native communities
Anna V. Smith (High Country News)